When God Seems Hidden

“The days are surely coming,” says the LORD, “when I will fulfill the promise I made to the house of Israel and the house of Judah. In those days and at that time I will cause a righteous Branch to spring up for David; and he shall execute justice and righteousness in the land” [Jeremiah 33:14-15 (NRSV)].

In sanctuaries across the world this Sunday, a single candle will pierce the darkness. A voice will proclaim ancient words of hope, speaking of promises made and fulfilled. The familiar rhythm of Advent begins again, calling us to wait with expectation for the One who is to come.

But for many, this first flame throws shadows as much as light. Indeed, many come to this season bearing burdens too heavy for ritual alone to lift: empty chairs at holiday tables, medical diagnoses that arrived without warning, the aftermath of senseless violence, the grinding weight of systemic injustice, or simply the deep ache of God’s seeming absence. For them—perhaps for us— the practiced words of Advent hope may ring hollow against the hard surfaces of lived experience.

It is into such questions that the prophet Jeremiah speaks. In this Sunday’s Old Testament lesson, Jeremiah 33:14-16 [First Sunday of Advent, RCL, Year C], we encounter words that come not from a place of comfortable religious observance, but from the depths of national catastrophe and collective grief. As we turn to the text that we designate as Chapter 33, we find ourselves in conversation with a people who knew intimately what it meant to question God’s presence, to wonder if divine promises could possibly hold true when everything stable had crumbled away.

Indeed, Jeremiah’s world was unraveling. The great city of Jerusalem, symbol of God’s presence and protection, stood on the brink of catastrophe. The Babylonian army pressed against its walls, while inside, the leadership that should have offered stability had instead delivered corruption and faithlessness. To make matters worse, Jeremiah himself spoke these words from prison—hardly a position that suggested divine favor or prophetic authority.

In such circumstances, God’s seeming hiddenness wasn’t merely a spiritual abstraction. It was written in the smoke rising from burning villages, in the growing desperation on children’s faces, in the bitter taste of fear that permeated every conversation. The people who had long proclaimed themselves as God’s chosen now faced the terrifying possibility that God had turned away, leaving them to the mercy of history’s cruel logic.

It is precisely here—in this moment of profound displacement and apparent divine absence—that Jeremiah speaks of a “righteous Branch” that will spring up for David. The promise’s audacity is staggering. When every branch of David’s line seems withered, when justice appears to have fled the earth, when righteousness feels like a cruel joke, Jeremiah dares to speak of new growth emerging from what looks like dead wood.

“The Lord is our righteousness,” he proclaims, using (according to one of my commentaries) the Hebrew phrase “YHWH tsidkenu” — a statement that locates the source of righteousness not in human achievement or institutional stability, but in God’s own character. This is no cheap optimism, no mere hoping for the best. It is instead a radical claim that God’s faithfulness operates precisely where human faithfulness has failed, that divine promises hold true even when—especially when—all human guarantees have crumbled.

Our own experience of divine hiddenness may take different forms than Jeremiah’s, but it cuts just as deep. For some, it comes in the silence after the doctor’s words have stopped echoing in the consultation room. For others, it emerges in the aftermath of broken trust and fractured relationships, when families splinter, and sacred bonds unravel. Still others encounter it through acts of violence that shake our sense of security, or in the quiet erosion of certainty that comes with sustained suffering or unanswered prayers. The questions we ask may be different from those of ancient Jerusalem, but they spring from the same root: Where is God when the foundations shake? What becomes of divine promises when every human assurance has failed? How do we speak of hope when experience teaches us to expect disappointment?

For those of us who have walked through valleys of shadow—whether personal, communal, or societal—this text offers neither easy answers nor quick escape. Instead, it suggests something far more profound: that God’s apparent absence does not negate God’s actual presence, that divine hiddenness does not equal divine abandonment, that hope can take root in the very soil of despair.

Advent asks us not to deny the darkness, but rather to trust that even here, especially here, God is at work bringing forth new life. Advent invites us to understand waiting not as passive endurance, but as active resistance against despair. The lighting of that first Advent candle becomes not just ritual, but rebellion—a stubborn insistence that shadows, however deep, do not have the final word.

When Jeremiah spoke of the righteous Branch, he wasn’t offering his people an escape from their present reality. Instead, he was naming a truth too deep for their circumstances to defeat: that God’s promises take root and grow even in soil that appears poisoned by loss, betrayal, or grief. The branch grows not despite the darkness, but through it.

This is the paradox that Advent sets before us. We are called to be a people who can hold both profound loss and profound hope, who can acknowledge divine hiddenness while trusting divine faithfulness, who can name the reality of suffering while refusing to grant it ultimate power over our lives. We light our candles not because the darkness is gone, but because we trust the One who moves in that darkness, bringing forth life where we see only death, cultivating justice where we experience only wrong.

As we enter this Advent season, may we find courage to stand with those who know God’s hiddenness all too well. May we resist the temptation to offer easy answers or premature comfort. And may we dare to believe, with Jeremiah, that even now—especially now—God’s righteousness is taking root in the broken soil of our world, preparing to break forth in ways we cannot yet imagine but dare to trust.